Back to guidesEmployment Law Guide

Performance Management at Work – Your Rights, Fair Process, and How to Respond

Performance management should be a supportive process designed to help employees succeed — not a shortcut to disciplinary action or dismissal. When handled properly, it identifies training needs, clarifies expectations, and improves working relationships. When handled poorly, it can be unfair, stressful, and even unlawful.

What Is Performance Management?

Performance management is the structured process employers use to:

  • Set expectations
  • Review performance
  • Identify support needs
  • Provide feedback
  • Address capability concerns

It should be fair, transparent, and focused on improvement, not punishment.

Your Rights in a Performance Management Process

1. Clear Expectations and Objectives

Your employer must give you:

  • Clear job responsibilities
  • Measurable performance targets
  • Realistic deadlines
  • Access to relevant policies

2. Proper Training and Support

Before raising concerns, employers must ensure you have:

  • Adequate training
  • Reasonable workload
  • Necessary tools and resources
  • Clear guidance

3. A Fair and Evidence Based Process

Performance concerns must be based on:

  • Facts
  • Data
  • Examples
  • Documented issues

Not assumptions, personal dislike, or inconsistent standards.

4. Reasonable Time to Improve

You must be given:

  • A structured improvement plan
  • Regular review meetings
  • Time to demonstrate progress

5. The Right to Challenge Unfair Assessments

You can challenge:

  • Inaccurate feedback
  • Unreasonable targets
  • Biased reviews
  • Lack of support

What Employers Must Do in a Fair Performance Process

1. Setting SMART Objectives

Targets must be:

  • Specific
  • Measurable
  • Achievable
  • Relevant
  • Time bound

2. Regular Check Ins

Your manager should meet with you to:

  • Review progress
  • Offer support
  • Adjust targets if needed

3. Providing Training and Resources

This may include:

  • Coaching
  • Mentoring
  • Additional training
  • Reduced workload
  • Updated tools or systems

4. Documenting Everything

Employers should keep:

  • Notes of meetings
  • Copies of objectives
  • Evidence of concerns
  • Records of support offered

5. Avoiding Discrimination

Performance management must not be influenced by:

  • Disability
  • Pregnancy
  • Age
  • Race
  • Sex
  • Religion
  • Any protected characteristic

Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs)

A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) is a formal document outlining:

  • Areas of concern
  • Targets for improvement
  • Support to be provided
  • Timescales
  • Review dates

Signs a Performance Process May Be Unfair

  • Targets are unrealistic or constantly changing
  • You're compared unfairly to others
  • You're denied training or support
  • Your manager is hostile or biased
  • Issues appear suddenly with no prior feedback
  • You're being managed out of the business
  • You're being punished for raising concerns or a grievance

How to Protect Yourself During Performance Management

  • Request written objectives
  • Ask for evidence of concerns
  • Keep your own notes
  • Request training or support
  • Follow up meetings in writing
  • Challenge inaccuracies immediately
  • Stay factual and professional
  • Ask for reasonable adjustments if needed

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, but only after a fair process, proper support, and reasonable time to improve.

performance

Need Support With Performance Management?

A fair performance process should help you succeed — not set you up to fail. If you're facing unfair treatment, biased reviews, or unrealistic expectations, expert guidance can protect your job and wellbeing.

Get Confidential Advice